Wednesday, 16 April 2003
Toothpaste Tube
If you grew up in London, like me, this map will strongly readjust your mental model of the city.
Tuesday, 15 April 2003
Opposites react
Dorothea continues documenting her ambivalent relationship with academia by pointing to an essay on academic alienation by a marxist ex-academic, who urges the abandonment of ambivalence for commitment.
I can see that may sound less than enticing, but it may help explain a widely noted phenomenon:
[...] this is not another story about how Berkeley is better than Knoxville.� Most of the ways it is (and of course it is) are obvious, and the last thing the� people reading this essay need is the sense of this superiority reinforced, as though the very real struggles of the UT students who I fell in love with year after year are somehow less significant because Knoxville has fewer cultural and political resources than Berkeley.� Rather, this is the story of the forms of disengagement that structure academic departments in general.� Certainly at the top of the profession, in places like Berkeley, scholars are far more likely than at UT to be engaged in national conversations. Yet at every level of the academic institution, a variety of individuals find that the best or easiest way to keep themselves going is by staying out of the way of department life.� At prestigious schools, where people actually have the money to do so, this results in the incessant flying around the world making connections, and the consequent political overvaluation of the so-called global over working in local institutions.� This itself is a form of disengagement.� At the University of Tennessee -- which is nowhere near the "bottom" as these things are assessed -- most faculty members are involved in neither national or local conversations, and as a result become altogether disengaged.
[...] I went from being a participant in specific, local, political movements to being� "global," or at least travelling all the time.� Because there weren't enough people in Knoxville who shared my interests.� [...]� Some academics build genuinely useful networks; others simply avoid responsibility for what needs to be done where they are.
I can see that may sound less than enticing, but it may help explain a widely noted phenomenon:
[...] this is not another story about how Berkeley is better than Knoxville.� Most of the ways it is (and of course it is) are obvious, and the last thing the� people reading this essay need is the sense of this superiority reinforced, as though the very real struggles of the UT students who I fell in love with year after year are somehow less significant because Knoxville has fewer cultural and political resources than Berkeley.� Rather, this is the story of the forms of disengagement that structure academic departments in general.� Certainly at the top of the profession, in places like Berkeley, scholars are far more likely than at UT to be engaged in national conversations. Yet at every level of the academic institution, a variety of individuals find that the best or easiest way to keep themselves going is by staying out of the way of department life.� At prestigious schools, where people actually have the money to do so, this results in the incessant flying around the world making connections, and the consequent political overvaluation of the so-called global over working in local institutions.� This itself is a form of disengagement.� At the University of Tennessee -- which is nowhere near the "bottom" as these things are assessed -- most faculty members are involved in neither national or local conversations, and as a result become altogether disengaged.
[...] I went from being a participant in specific, local, political movements to being� "global," or at least travelling all the time.� Because there weren't enough people in Knoxville who shared my interests.� [...]� Some academics build genuinely useful networks; others simply avoid responsibility for what needs to be done where they are.
Wolfram speaks
Stephen Wolfram, Author of Mathematica and 'A New Kind of Science' was invited to speak by my employer today. Here are my running notes of his talk:
How do structures form?
1st assumption - easy to do; didn't work.
Approach fundamentally wrong - mathematical analysis worked for simpler phenomena, what can you do differently?
Previously based on existing mathematics; wanted a more general construct, which led him to programs.
Consider space of all possible programs, and consider what kinds of programs are found in nature. Mathematica is a new tool like telescope or microscope - reveals the computational world.
256 1-d Cellular Automata is a simple program space to explore. (If you're running OS X, try my program that draws them)
Patterns in nature look more complex than man-made things. The simple rules can give rise to natural complexity - mollusc shells have very similar patterns.
Without computational tools it is hard to see these patterns; people looked for regularity not irregularities.
Principle of Computational Equivalence - complex systems are of equivalent computation. Not linear - phase transitions between kinds of sophistication.
Computational limit is achieved often.
Is rule 30 computationally universal? No, but 110 is. You can make a Turing machine from rule 100 - it is computationally universal.
If the observer is computationally more complex than the system, they can see the patterns; in practice the observer is equivalent in complexity, so systems can look complex.
For a system that is linear or repetitive, you can find out an arbitrary future state; for a computationally complex system you can't. Simulation is necessary, not just convenient.
Mathematics has chosen a subset of possible systems that are tractable, rather than complete.
Simple underlying equations of physics - a 14 bn year program. CA's not appropriate. Do not distinguish matter and space, just define space. Think of space as like water - looks continuous, but is made of interacting particles. Underlying space is a network of nodes with connections between them. Look at dimensionality d dimension r^d nodes.
Are space and time different or not? He thinks yes. Global sync like a CA? Not needed. Consider a single active cell that moves change around. Can only follow the causal network, so you only know others have changed when you get updated too.
Can derive special relativity from the low level network model, and move on to General Relativity.
Not yet derived Quantum Mechanics, but can model particle interactions.
Ongoing reduction of 'specialness' - every time we get less special, science gets more general. Simple abstract systems are as computationally complex as we are.
Process of paradigm shifts - see notes in back of book.
Mathematica - algorithm resource base. Mathematica notebooks as publication model. Symbolic language under Mathematica - symbolic structures.
Schr�dinger's equation relating to these systems - do they apply to PDE's? Yes - start with a Gaussian distribution, get the same kinds of complexity. Can one make PDE's from discrete systems? Yes can do it with fluid mechanics.
Can't derive Schr�dinger's equation at the moment. Rigid body mechanics is harder than fluid mechanics.
Bells inequality - atoms can be joined through the 'space' network - only approximately 3-dimensional.
PCE vs awareness & consciousness? Hierarchy - life, intelligence, consciousness.
Life definition gets harder as we get machines and programs. Life as we know it has a common ancestor, so there is a historical definition. PCE says there is not a general notion of intelligence or consciousness - they are connected through our 'computational history' through pre-existing evolution. Self-awareness 'Real-time philosophy is hard'. Neural net approach to brain modelling is static - machinery is continuum dynamics.
Penrose's discrete and continuous equations - discrete space 'spin networks' fit with the network model of Wolfram. Penrose thinks computers are different from humans. Penrose's view of computing is that brains are different - he considers computers do predicate logic, and is wrong. Continuum vs discrete mathematics - had thought that continuum could transcend Turing, but can't prove, but can't find examples.
I asked him about the connection between his categories and the applicability of the Central Limit Theorem, and he pointed out that while it would break down for his complex systems, it will also break down for long-tailed distributions too.
How do structures form?
1st assumption - easy to do; didn't work.
Approach fundamentally wrong - mathematical analysis worked for simpler phenomena, what can you do differently?
Previously based on existing mathematics; wanted a more general construct, which led him to programs.
Consider space of all possible programs, and consider what kinds of programs are found in nature. Mathematica is a new tool like telescope or microscope - reveals the computational world.
256 1-d Cellular Automata is a simple program space to explore. (If you're running OS X, try my program that draws them)
Patterns in nature look more complex than man-made things. The simple rules can give rise to natural complexity - mollusc shells have very similar patterns.
Without computational tools it is hard to see these patterns; people looked for regularity not irregularities.
Principle of Computational Equivalence - complex systems are of equivalent computation. Not linear - phase transitions between kinds of sophistication.
Computational limit is achieved often.
Is rule 30 computationally universal? No, but 110 is. You can make a Turing machine from rule 100 - it is computationally universal.
If the observer is computationally more complex than the system, they can see the patterns; in practice the observer is equivalent in complexity, so systems can look complex.
For a system that is linear or repetitive, you can find out an arbitrary future state; for a computationally complex system you can't. Simulation is necessary, not just convenient.
Mathematics has chosen a subset of possible systems that are tractable, rather than complete.
Simple underlying equations of physics - a 14 bn year program. CA's not appropriate. Do not distinguish matter and space, just define space. Think of space as like water - looks continuous, but is made of interacting particles. Underlying space is a network of nodes with connections between them. Look at dimensionality d dimension r^d nodes.
Are space and time different or not? He thinks yes. Global sync like a CA? Not needed. Consider a single active cell that moves change around. Can only follow the causal network, so you only know others have changed when you get updated too.
Can derive special relativity from the low level network model, and move on to General Relativity.
Not yet derived Quantum Mechanics, but can model particle interactions.
Ongoing reduction of 'specialness' - every time we get less special, science gets more general. Simple abstract systems are as computationally complex as we are.
Process of paradigm shifts - see notes in back of book.
Mathematica - algorithm resource base. Mathematica notebooks as publication model. Symbolic language under Mathematica - symbolic structures.
Schr�dinger's equation relating to these systems - do they apply to PDE's? Yes - start with a Gaussian distribution, get the same kinds of complexity. Can one make PDE's from discrete systems? Yes can do it with fluid mechanics.
Can't derive Schr�dinger's equation at the moment. Rigid body mechanics is harder than fluid mechanics.
Bells inequality - atoms can be joined through the 'space' network - only approximately 3-dimensional.
PCE vs awareness & consciousness? Hierarchy - life, intelligence, consciousness.
Life definition gets harder as we get machines and programs. Life as we know it has a common ancestor, so there is a historical definition. PCE says there is not a general notion of intelligence or consciousness - they are connected through our 'computational history' through pre-existing evolution. Self-awareness 'Real-time philosophy is hard'. Neural net approach to brain modelling is static - machinery is continuum dynamics.
Penrose's discrete and continuous equations - discrete space 'spin networks' fit with the network model of Wolfram. Penrose thinks computers are different from humans. Penrose's view of computing is that brains are different - he considers computers do predicate logic, and is wrong. Continuum vs discrete mathematics - had thought that continuum could transcend Turing, but can't prove, but can't find examples.
I asked him about the connection between his categories and the applicability of the Central Limit Theorem, and he pointed out that while it would break down for his complex systems, it will also break down for long-tailed distributions too.
Saturday, 5 April 2003
Blogs as Kritarchy
I've been reading a long paper about Kritarchy - governance by justice, and have realised that it describes weblogs rather well. A quote:
it is no more than a historical accident that the word �law� came to be used as the translation of �lex�. It was also and more properly used to translate the Latin �ius�, which has nothing to do with the exercise of political authority. �Ius� denotes a bond or obligation arising out of a personal commitment made in solemn speech (�iurare�, to swear) and in a more general sense the order of human affairs that arises out of such mutual commitments. In other words, �ius� presupposes a condition in which people meet as free and equal persons and arrange their affairs by mutual agreements, contracts or covenants. This is in clear contrast to �lex�, which presupposes that one man can unilaterally oblige another.
The notion is of people interacting through mutual consent, conforming to natural law - justice is determined from the Golden rule and its philosophical ramifications.
In the physical world, contention over scarce resources undermines this; in the virtual world we can all be judges of each other's thoughts and writings, as there is no coercion for others to read them.
it is no more than a historical accident that the word �law� came to be used as the translation of �lex�. It was also and more properly used to translate the Latin �ius�, which has nothing to do with the exercise of political authority. �Ius� denotes a bond or obligation arising out of a personal commitment made in solemn speech (�iurare�, to swear) and in a more general sense the order of human affairs that arises out of such mutual commitments. In other words, �ius� presupposes a condition in which people meet as free and equal persons and arrange their affairs by mutual agreements, contracts or covenants. This is in clear contrast to �lex�, which presupposes that one man can unilaterally oblige another.
The notion is of people interacting through mutual consent, conforming to natural law - justice is determined from the Golden rule and its philosophical ramifications.
In the physical world, contention over scarce resources undermines this; in the virtual world we can all be judges of each other's thoughts and writings, as there is no coercion for others to read them.
Keep the spectrum, keep it open
Mike Godwin has a suggestion to avoid the Digital TV impasse. Allow each TV station to decide whether to keep the digital spectrum and return the analog, or vice versa, and require them to make their programs available for internet download,
Personally, I don't understand why no-one has pointed out the missing principle in this debate. If TV stations are to be given local monopoly rights over big chunks of public spectrum, they should be required to not encumber their transmissions with encryption or access control, so the public can freely receive their shows.
Personally, I don't understand why no-one has pointed out the missing principle in this debate. If TV stations are to be given local monopoly rights over big chunks of public spectrum, they should be required to not encumber their transmissions with encryption or access control, so the public can freely receive their shows.
shooting people to create a demand for hospitals
A wonderful anti-DRM analogy from 'Sanity' on Slashdot:
Capitalism is a means to manage scarcity, and it is very good at it, but artifically creating scarcity just so that capitalism may be applied is like shooting people to create a demand for hospitals:
"stop shooting people!"
"what, you don't like hospitals?"
Capitalism is a means to manage scarcity, and it is very good at it, but artifically creating scarcity just so that capitalism may be applied is like shooting people to create a demand for hospitals:
"stop shooting people!"
"what, you don't like hospitals?"
Friday, 4 April 2003
Simultaneous editing
Hydra is a very nice implementation of this idea - you share your document to the net and people can edit it at the same time as you (you get to choose who). It uses Rendezvous and Addressbook, so you get user icons like iChat.
Jem wrote something very similar nearly 10 years ago before we dragged him into Newton development. His ran over LocalTalk, but it did allow two people to modify the same file at once.
NB Hydra is OS X only.
Jem wrote something very similar nearly 10 years ago before we dragged him into Newton development. His ran over LocalTalk, but it did allow two people to modify the same file at once.
NB Hydra is OS X only.
Thursday, 3 April 2003
Googlewash? Hogwash.
Andrew Orlowski has written a rant about bloggers 'googlewashing' the phrase 'second superpower'.
Separating out the bizarre attacks on Joi Ito for eating lunch, his thesis seems to be that 'A-list bloggers' have hijacked and neutered the phrase from the Anti-war (or anti-Bush) protesters, and swamped Google with this new interpretation.
In fact, the original article he cites (reproduced here) did not contain the phrase 'second superpower'; it had a throwaway rhetorical flourish in the first sentence:
The fracturing of the Western alliance over Iraq and the huge antiwar demonstrations around the world this weekend are reminders that there may still be two superpowers on the planet: the United States and world public opinion.
(Orlowski elides the first part about the Western alliance to support his thesis that it's all about the street, man).
As he says, this meme circulated about the web a bit, and eventually James Moore explored the idea in more detail, and a broader context than just marching against Bush, combining it with the preceding discussions on 'emergent democracy' that had been going for a while. Of course this gets a higher rank for 'second superpower' - it is in the title, and enough people found it interesting enough to link to. (Update: today the NYT removed its archives from the web, so any links to the original article would now be dead).
Instead of a lot of incoherent slogans, here are people discussing how to bring it about.
Orlowski then completely distorts the quote from Patrick Nielsen Hayden I posted to the list. Discussing a report on the very disruptive, street-blocking protests, where protesters in San Francisco, Boston, Washington and elsewhere shouted the same slogan, "This is what democracy looks like!"
Patrick said
No, that's not what democracy looks like.
It's what protest looks like, and it's often the right thing to do. And of course "democracy" had better entail significant tolerance of unruly protest, or it's not very democratic.
But that slogan is stupid, even by the standards of slogans. Long and often boring meetings are what democracy looks like. Tiresome horse-trading is what democracy looks like. Talking to your neighbors is what democracy looks like.
Democracy can function perfectly well without people painting their faces and blocking streets. It can't function at all without that other stuff.
The emergent democracy group is about how to build tools and structures to capture democratic intent in a digital world. If you're interested in this, join in.
Perhaps what Orlowski is really worried about is that a group who aren't part of the clerisy of professional Journalists and activists are taking an interest, and actually discussing ideas calmly and rationally, and thereby attracting links from other people, Doc and Dave earned their high Google rankings by writing lots of things that people found interesting enough to link to, day after day for many years.
Andrew, if you have interesting things to say about the future of democracy, join the discussion, but don't troll for cheap links by stooping to selective quotation and ad hominem attacks.
Coda:
I like to link to Orwell's Politics and the English Language essay at least once a year, if only to remind myself to re-read it. Mr Orlowski could profit from reviewing it too. His neologism 'googlewash' falls down on Orwell's criterion of creating a meaningful metaphor. Orlowski derives it from 'greenwash' which evidently derives from 'whitewash' - to paint over flaws to give a gleaming exterior. Yet 'googlewash' does not follow here - the complaint is not that the new google-friendly definition is hiding the flaws of the old, is it?
As Orwell puts it:
The writer either has a meaning and cannot express it, or he inadvertently says something else, or he is almost indifferent as to whether his words mean anything or not.
Separating out the bizarre attacks on Joi Ito for eating lunch, his thesis seems to be that 'A-list bloggers' have hijacked and neutered the phrase from the Anti-war (or anti-Bush) protesters, and swamped Google with this new interpretation.
In fact, the original article he cites (reproduced here) did not contain the phrase 'second superpower'; it had a throwaway rhetorical flourish in the first sentence:
The fracturing of the Western alliance over Iraq and the huge antiwar demonstrations around the world this weekend are reminders that there may still be two superpowers on the planet: the United States and world public opinion.
(Orlowski elides the first part about the Western alliance to support his thesis that it's all about the street, man).
As he says, this meme circulated about the web a bit, and eventually James Moore explored the idea in more detail, and a broader context than just marching against Bush, combining it with the preceding discussions on 'emergent democracy' that had been going for a while. Of course this gets a higher rank for 'second superpower' - it is in the title, and enough people found it interesting enough to link to. (Update: today the NYT removed its archives from the web, so any links to the original article would now be dead).
Instead of a lot of incoherent slogans, here are people discussing how to bring it about.
Orlowski then completely distorts the quote from Patrick Nielsen Hayden I posted to the list. Discussing a report on the very disruptive, street-blocking protests, where protesters in San Francisco, Boston, Washington and elsewhere shouted the same slogan, "This is what democracy looks like!"
Patrick said
No, that's not what democracy looks like.
It's what protest looks like, and it's often the right thing to do. And of course "democracy" had better entail significant tolerance of unruly protest, or it's not very democratic.
But that slogan is stupid, even by the standards of slogans. Long and often boring meetings are what democracy looks like. Tiresome horse-trading is what democracy looks like. Talking to your neighbors is what democracy looks like.
Democracy can function perfectly well without people painting their faces and blocking streets. It can't function at all without that other stuff.
The emergent democracy group is about how to build tools and structures to capture democratic intent in a digital world. If you're interested in this, join in.
Perhaps what Orlowski is really worried about is that a group who aren't part of the clerisy of professional Journalists and activists are taking an interest, and actually discussing ideas calmly and rationally, and thereby attracting links from other people, Doc and Dave earned their high Google rankings by writing lots of things that people found interesting enough to link to, day after day for many years.
Andrew, if you have interesting things to say about the future of democracy, join the discussion, but don't troll for cheap links by stooping to selective quotation and ad hominem attacks.
Coda:
I like to link to Orwell's Politics and the English Language essay at least once a year, if only to remind myself to re-read it. Mr Orlowski could profit from reviewing it too. His neologism 'googlewash' falls down on Orwell's criterion of creating a meaningful metaphor. Orlowski derives it from 'greenwash' which evidently derives from 'whitewash' - to paint over flaws to give a gleaming exterior. Yet 'googlewash' does not follow here - the complaint is not that the new google-friendly definition is hiding the flaws of the old, is it?
As Orwell puts it:
The writer either has a meaning and cannot express it, or he inadvertently says something else, or he is almost indifferent as to whether his words mean anything or not.
Wednesday, 2 April 2003
Thursday, 27 March 2003
Alienaid - Ports - UK to Iraq
HEARD ON SKY NEWS
"Umm Qasr is a town similar to Southampton", UK Defence Minister Geoff Hoon told the House of Commons yesterday. "He's either never been to Southampton, or he's never been to Umm Qasr", said one British soldier, informed of this while on patrol in Umm Qasr. Another added: "There's no beer, no prostitutes, and people are shooting at us. It's more like Portsmouth."
via William Gibson
"Umm Qasr is a town similar to Southampton", UK Defence Minister Geoff Hoon told the House of Commons yesterday. "He's either never been to Southampton, or he's never been to Umm Qasr", said one British soldier, informed of this while on patrol in Umm Qasr. Another added: "There's no beer, no prostitutes, and people are shooting at us. It's more like Portsmouth."
via William Gibson
Wednesday, 26 March 2003
Tragedy of the Commons and dog turds
I need to do another post on the Vote Links idea, but I have been busy working on a very local democratic issue - countering a proposal to convert the Park at the end of my garden into a Dog Park.
If any of you could spare the time to review my argument (which discusses the Tragedy of the Commons and the concept of leeway in law, as well as dog turds) and offer comments on how it could be improved, I'd be very grateful.
If you live in the SV area and want to email councillors or attend the Council meeting, let me know too.
See if you can guess which park is at the end of my garden...
If any of you could spare the time to review my argument (which discusses the Tragedy of the Commons and the concept of leeway in law, as well as dog turds) and offer comments on how it could be improved, I'd be very grateful.
If you live in the SV area and want to email councillors or attend the Council meeting, let me know too.
See if you can guess which park is at the end of my garden...
Tuesday, 25 March 2003
Mass media set on Baghdad blogger
Poor Salam. He's not just sitting in Baghdad wondering if he's going to to be bombed, he's been spammed by the US government, dissed by the Wall Street Journal and now USA Today the AP, the NYT and many more are jumping on the bandwagon.
The last Gulf War made CNN's reputation; this one is doing it for weblogs.
The last Gulf War made CNN's reputation; this one is doing it for weblogs.
Friday, 21 March 2003
AlienAid - Newspaper opinion - UK to US
I don't plan to add to the mountain of verbiage flooding online about the Iraq war, but I find myself turning to media from England as well as weblogs, and thought I'd pass some links on.
Last week's Spectator has some good opinion pieces on the war and background. Roger Scruton made a point in his essay about the Anglosphere vs EU/UN split that meshes well with the 'emergent democracy' ideas (he earlier talked about avoiding the tyranny of the majority) :
England gave us other good things besides the richest language and most powerful literature in modern Europe. In particular it gave us the common law. Our law is not a collection of decrees dictated by the sovereign but a developing set of answers to concrete human conflicts, discovered by impartial judges in the courts. It embodies the old idea of natural justice, according to which law stands in judgment over the sovereign and does not merely transmit his decrees. The common law is the true origin of our freedoms, of our safety in the face of state power, and of our ability to lead our own lives, however eccentric, without asking anyone’s permission. The EU has been built upon a conception of legal order that takes the decree (or ‘directive’) rather than the particular case and its ratio decidendi, as its paradigm. This, in my view, is the real reason why the English rebel against it — even those who have no knowledge of the history and the inherited conception of justice that make this rebellion inevitable, obligatory and right. [...]
Our Bill of Rights was taken up and re-affirmed in the first Ten Amendments to the American Constitution. This fundamentally backward-looking document did not destroy the common-law jurisdiction, but upheld it, both endorsing its principles and ensuring that the courts remain the final source of law — which is why the American Constitution can now be understood only through 400 or so volumes of case law. In this and many other respects the US Constitution is heir to the Anglo-Saxon experience of law, as the voice of the people against the sovereign, and the defender of individual freedom against the state. This experience separates both us and the Americans from the history of Continental Europe since the Reformation.
The Telegraph's Opinion Page has a good mix of views, from Peter Simple:
Now Tony Blair has his way and his war. It is, he says, a war against chaos, for which the whole world must unite. So the "war against terror" makes way for the "war against chaos", another war against an abstract noun and as nonsensical as the "war against racism" or the "war against poverty".
Chaos is within us. Will the war against Iraq be the beginning of a process in which the whole world will descend into chaos, no piece of politician's rhetoric but terrible reality, a state from which it may never emerge?
to Armando Ianucci's lament for the 'Stop the War' protests:
the anti-war movement collapsed into the usual non-media-friendly succession of images we often associate with lost causes; threadbare lines of wackily dressed people holding candles, celebrities with masking tape over their mouths, "resting" actresses saying it's all appalling.
Not good. Stop the War was just not savvy, not cynical enough, to steal Blair's 1997 clothes, and make each and every one of its spokesmen look respectable, look the part, on message and on focus, appealing to Middle England.
to Adel Darwish on Saddam's favourite movie:
Saddam's favourite film, he told us that afternoon, was The Godfather - and he seemed, as president, to become the personification of Al Pacino's murderous gangster Michael Corleone.
In that film, the shooting of the Godfather throws New York's underworld into anarchy, confusion and bloodshed. George W Bush and Tony Blair might do well to heed the parallel. The disappearance of Saddam from the scene could throw the region into just such confusion, and they may be in no doubt that Saddam will make every effort to maximise that effect.
Even the Grauniad has a couple of good articles- one on TV's hunger for 'shock and awe', combined with its determination to keep showing news even when nothing is new, and another on the way Cruise missiles changed war.
The Economist explains why people believe complex conspiracy theories
So why does London have richer opinion pages than New York ?
Boris Johnson suggests one reason.
![]() | The BBC World Service has ongoing coverage that is clear with the headlines on the hour and has lots of interesting backstory inbetween. They try to stay impartial, despite being based in Bush House (which does have 'Nation shall speak Peace unto Nation' engraved on the facade). BBC Radio Five Live is quite good too. Shame the streams keep dropping out.
This page is close to being an aggregator of journalists blogs, except they change the URL every day |
Last week's Spectator has some good opinion pieces on the war and background. Roger Scruton made a point in his essay about the Anglosphere vs EU/UN split that meshes well with the 'emergent democracy' ideas (he earlier talked about avoiding the tyranny of the majority) :
England gave us other good things besides the richest language and most powerful literature in modern Europe. In particular it gave us the common law. Our law is not a collection of decrees dictated by the sovereign but a developing set of answers to concrete human conflicts, discovered by impartial judges in the courts. It embodies the old idea of natural justice, according to which law stands in judgment over the sovereign and does not merely transmit his decrees. The common law is the true origin of our freedoms, of our safety in the face of state power, and of our ability to lead our own lives, however eccentric, without asking anyone’s permission. The EU has been built upon a conception of legal order that takes the decree (or ‘directive’) rather than the particular case and its ratio decidendi, as its paradigm. This, in my view, is the real reason why the English rebel against it — even those who have no knowledge of the history and the inherited conception of justice that make this rebellion inevitable, obligatory and right. [...]
Our Bill of Rights was taken up and re-affirmed in the first Ten Amendments to the American Constitution. This fundamentally backward-looking document did not destroy the common-law jurisdiction, but upheld it, both endorsing its principles and ensuring that the courts remain the final source of law — which is why the American Constitution can now be understood only through 400 or so volumes of case law. In this and many other respects the US Constitution is heir to the Anglo-Saxon experience of law, as the voice of the people against the sovereign, and the defender of individual freedom against the state. This experience separates both us and the Americans from the history of Continental Europe since the Reformation.
The Telegraph's Opinion Page has a good mix of views, from Peter Simple:
Now Tony Blair has his way and his war. It is, he says, a war against chaos, for which the whole world must unite. So the "war against terror" makes way for the "war against chaos", another war against an abstract noun and as nonsensical as the "war against racism" or the "war against poverty".
Chaos is within us. Will the war against Iraq be the beginning of a process in which the whole world will descend into chaos, no piece of politician's rhetoric but terrible reality, a state from which it may never emerge?
to Armando Ianucci's lament for the 'Stop the War' protests:
the anti-war movement collapsed into the usual non-media-friendly succession of images we often associate with lost causes; threadbare lines of wackily dressed people holding candles, celebrities with masking tape over their mouths, "resting" actresses saying it's all appalling.
Not good. Stop the War was just not savvy, not cynical enough, to steal Blair's 1997 clothes, and make each and every one of its spokesmen look respectable, look the part, on message and on focus, appealing to Middle England.
to Adel Darwish on Saddam's favourite movie:
Saddam's favourite film, he told us that afternoon, was The Godfather - and he seemed, as president, to become the personification of Al Pacino's murderous gangster Michael Corleone.
In that film, the shooting of the Godfather throws New York's underworld into anarchy, confusion and bloodshed. George W Bush and Tony Blair might do well to heed the parallel. The disappearance of Saddam from the scene could throw the region into just such confusion, and they may be in no doubt that Saddam will make every effort to maximise that effect.
Even the Grauniad has a couple of good articles- one on TV's hunger for 'shock and awe', combined with its determination to keep showing news even when nothing is new, and another on the way Cruise missiles changed war.
The Economist explains why people believe complex conspiracy theories
So why does London have richer opinion pages than New York ?
Boris Johnson suggests one reason.
Thursday, 20 March 2003
DRM Destroys Value - Jupiter has proof
DRM Destroys Value - I've been saying this for a while, but Jupiter's new survey backs it up with figures:
According to the study, nearly twice as many online consumers are willing to pay $17.99 for a CD that has unrestricted copy abilities versus a CD at only $9.99 that cannot be copied.
That is a somewhat convoluted sentence, but it is pretty clear that DRM would cost the companies more than their profit margin to use (and it wouldn't stop copying in any case).
According to the study, nearly twice as many online consumers are willing to pay $17.99 for a CD that has unrestricted copy abilities versus a CD at only $9.99 that cannot be copied.
That is a somewhat convoluted sentence, but it is pretty clear that DRM would cost the companies more than their profit margin to use (and it wouldn't stop copying in any case).
Friday, 14 March 2003
Vote Links
After much discussion with the emergent democracy gang, here is my proposal for Vote Links.
I propose that we add an optional attribute to the <a> (link) tag in HTML. Its name is 'vote'. Its value can be "+" "0" or "-", representing agreement, abstention or indifference, and disagreement respectively.
An untagged link is deemed to have value "+".
Additional human-readable commentary can be added using the existing 'title' attribute, which most browsers show as a rollover.
Examples:
Raging Cow
Raging Cow
Points that keep coming up:
Why only + and -? How about something more nuanced?
The point of this is to provide a strong yes/no response. Finer-grained measures of agreement don't make much sense on an individual basis; aggregating many votes is more interesting. For example, consider how eBay's user rating system has been reduced to a like/dislike switch by users. The 'Ayes, Noes, abstentions' model has served well in politics.
There are much richer ways to express this idea and similar ones using RDF and semantic web ideas
Indeed there are, but typing them by hand and remembering them is beyond most mere mortals, and automated tools don't do this either. This is meant to be very simple, memorable and easy to type in the current generation of blogging tools, that largely need manual entry of URLs.
I'd like some visual representation on the page of these different types
You can do that by defining 'voteyes' 'voteno' and 'abstain' classes in css and applying them to the post as well.
Won't all this negativity lead to trolling and flame wars?
Trolling is a problem already - Google's PageRank rewards being linked to, so notoreity is valued as highly as popularity. This leads to a 'no publicity is bad publicity' approach.
For relentless positivists, the '0' and '-' values could be taken as signals meaning "don't index this link". For Vote tallying, however, positive and negative responses are both valuable and clear.
The possibility of a personally filtered search, which reflects your own values expressed by your own links is gretaly enhanced by the ability to define neagative links as well.
More discussion:
Exhaustive taxonomy of link types Far too much complexity.
An earlier call for this kind of thing
John Lebovsky's variation on a theme
Steven Johnson channels Vonnegut on Karasses & Granfalloons
I propose that we add an optional attribute to the <a> (link) tag in HTML. Its name is 'vote'. Its value can be "+" "0" or "-", representing agreement, abstention or indifference, and disagreement respectively.
An untagged link is deemed to have value "+".
Additional human-readable commentary can be added using the existing 'title' attribute, which most browsers show as a rollover.
Examples:
<a href="http://ragingcow.blogspot.com" vote="+" title="neat spoof">Raging Cow</a>yields
Raging Cow
<a href="http://ragingcow.com" vote="-" title="nasty corn syrup drink">Raging Cow</a>yields
Raging Cow
Points that keep coming up:
Why only + and -? How about something more nuanced?
The point of this is to provide a strong yes/no response. Finer-grained measures of agreement don't make much sense on an individual basis; aggregating many votes is more interesting. For example, consider how eBay's user rating system has been reduced to a like/dislike switch by users. The 'Ayes, Noes, abstentions' model has served well in politics.
There are much richer ways to express this idea and similar ones using RDF and semantic web ideas
Indeed there are, but typing them by hand and remembering them is beyond most mere mortals, and automated tools don't do this either. This is meant to be very simple, memorable and easy to type in the current generation of blogging tools, that largely need manual entry of URLs.
I'd like some visual representation on the page of these different types
You can do that by defining 'voteyes' 'voteno' and 'abstain' classes in css and applying them to the post as well.
Won't all this negativity lead to trolling and flame wars?
Trolling is a problem already - Google's PageRank rewards being linked to, so notoreity is valued as highly as popularity. This leads to a 'no publicity is bad publicity' approach.
For relentless positivists, the '0' and '-' values could be taken as signals meaning "don't index this link". For Vote tallying, however, positive and negative responses are both valuable and clear.
The possibility of a personally filtered search, which reflects your own values expressed by your own links is gretaly enhanced by the ability to define neagative links as well.
More discussion:
Exhaustive taxonomy of link types Far too much complexity.
An earlier call for this kind of thing
John Lebovsky's variation on a theme
Steven Johnson channels Vonnegut on Karasses & Granfalloons
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



